In this section
START OF Factsheets and guides
START OF Factsheets
END OF Factsheets
END OF Factsheets and guides
Download print version(PDF, 316KB)
You have the right to appeal Centrelink’s decision to raise a debt.
Centrelink is using a new online compliance system to work out if people have received overpayments.
The system compares data held by Centrelink with other government agencies, including the Australian Tax Office (ATO), to see whether the employment information provided by a person to Centrelink matches up. If the system finds a difference between the income amount you reported to Centrelink and the ATO records, it will send you a letter advising of a potential debt and asking for more information about your income.
Flaws in this system have resulted in many people receiving inaccurate debt notices. The ATO data shows a person’s income for a given financial year and the automated system appears to be allocating that income equally across fortnights, where in fact a person may have been receiving welfare benefits for part of the year before resuming or starting employment.
There have also been reports of employer’s names being recorded differently in the Centrelink and ATO computer systems, which means when the data between the systems is ‘matched’, it appears the person had two jobs rather than one. There may be other flaws we are not yet aware of.
If the system shows a possible difference between income you reported to Centrelink and the information held by the ATO or other agencies:
If you don’t go online, the system will assume your employer and pay details are correct and will automatically assess and calculate the debt by averaging the total income across the employment period in the ATO records.
It also does this if you go online and confirm the information is correct but don’t enter details of your pay and pay periods.
If you no longer have copies of past payslips and other relevant information, then this should be considered a reasonable excuse not to provide the supporting documentation, because it is no longer within your 'possession or control'. However, if you do have supporting documentation and can access myGov to correct any errors, then you should do so. This does not affect your right to ask for a review of any debt Centrelink might later raise.
If you don’t respond to the letter before the deadline, the online system automatically calculates the debt based on the ATO information and adds a 10 percent recovery fee to the debt.
If you still don’t respond and you don’t arrange to pay the debt after Centrelink raises a debt notice, Centrelink may then send your case to a debt collector to find you and arrange for you to pay the debt. Centrelink may add interest to the debt in some circumstances.
You have the right to appeal almost any decision Centrelink makes about you and this includes the decision to raise a debt.
If you have received an Accounts payable notice from Centrelink, you can appeal by asking a Centrelink authorised review officer (ARO) to review the debt.
An ARO is a senior Centrelink officer who has not dealt with your matter before. They will have a fresh look at the decision and call you to discuss it. You can give new information to the ARO to consider. The ARO will confirm, change or cancel the debt.
The ARO must make the 'correct' decision based on all the information available. This means a debt could be increased, decreased or cancelled on review. However, this should not stop you from appealing. The ARO should send you a detailed letter explaining their decision.
You can ask an ARO to review the decision:
You can also ask Centrelink to suspend repayments while the review is taking place. If Centrelink decides not to suspend repayments, you can ask that an ARO also review that decision as well, and complain if Centrelink refuses to do so.
If a debt is cancelled on review, then any recovery fee should also be cancelled. If you have made repayments towards the debt in the meantime, you will get that money back.
Make sure you request a receipt number from Centrelink for every request you make and keep copies of any documents you give to Centrelink.
There is no time limit to ask for the ARO to review Centrelink’s decision about a debt. You can ask for a review from the ARO even if you have started to pay the debt and even if you have paid all of the debt.
If you aren’t happy with the ARO’s decision, you can appeal to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT).
The AAT is free and informal, but must apply the same laws as Centrelink does. Centrelink will provide information from your file and the AAT will schedule a hearing where you will have an opportunity to explain why you think the decision is wrong.
There are two AAT divisions that review Centrelink decisions. If you disagree with the outcome of the Social Security & Child Support Division (1st level), you can apply for a second review by the AAT’s General Division (2nd level).
If you don’t pay your debt, ask for a review by an ARO or enter into a payment plan by the due date, Centrelink may:
Dun and Bradstreet and the Probe Group are contracted by Centrelink to follow up debts and they may contact you by phone or letter to try and arrange for you to pay the debt.
If you have asked for an ARO review and are contacted by a debt collector, you can tell them you want the debt referred back to Centrelink because you are appealing the debt. You do not have to enter into a payment plan with a debt collector.
If you think a debt collector is harassing you or giving you misleading information, contact the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission on 1300 302 502.
If you aren’t happy with the service you have received from Centrelink, you can complain. If you make a complaint, it should not have any negative impact on your appeal.
You can complain if:
You can complain to:
Centrelink—1800 132 468 or www.humanservices.gov.au/customer/contact-us/complaints-and-feedback
Commonwealth Ombudsman—1300 362 072 or www.ombudsman.gov.au
Your local Member of Parliament—www.aph.gov.au/Senators_and_Members/Members
If you have suffered loss as a result of Centrelink’s conduct, you can apply for compensation under the Scheme for Compensation for Detriment caused by Defective Administration. For more information, see the Department of Finance website.
Legal Aid Queensland provides legal advice clinics at the AAT’s Social Security and Child Support Division (1st level) and General Division (2nd level) each week. If you lodge an appeal in the AAT, you can ask the AAT registry staff to book you into one of the clinics for advice about your appeal.
Basic Rights Queensland provides legal advice on Centrelink matters by phone. You can call 1800 358 511 to book in for advice.
Department of Human Services:
Acknowledgement: This factsheet has been adapted from the Victoria Legal Aid website.